JELL-O GELATIN — FAR FROM HOMEMADE™

Information updated January 2024

According to Statista 2024, Jell-O is the number one flavored gelatin dessert in the U.S.  There are really only a handful of people in America who've never had Jell-O! 

When Jell-O was first created in the late 1800's by a cough-syrup maker, Jell-O contained real fruit syrups. "PURE FRUIT FLAVOR"  was noted on the package front. 

JELL-O ORIGINALLY CONTAINED REAL FRUIT JUICE: Following are a couple of historical print ads stating that Strawberry Jell-O has, "Flavor captured from the actual juice of the sun-ripened fruit".

Now, Jell-O is made using Artificial Flavor and Artificial Colors.

(Source for NOW Jell-O Ingredients: Kraft Heinz Jell-O on Walmart Web site 1/24)

THEN vs. NOW: We see below the Jell-O evolution from 'Pure Fruit Flavor' + ‘Vegetable Color’ to 'Artificial Flavor' + ‘Artificial Color’.

The differences between the Jell-O Gelatin offerings are the use of different Artificial Flavors and Artificial Colors corresponding "consumer-expectation colors" >> what color would consumers expect Tropical Punch flavor to be? 

Other than the Artificial Flavors and Colors, each box of Jell-O is basically Sugar and Gelatin with some added chemical ingredients. 

Let's take a look at the ingredients in Kraft Heinz Jell-O Black Cherry Artificial Flavor Gelatin Dessert: (Source: Kraft Heinz Jell-O on Walmart Web site 1/24)

MODERN-DAY JELL-O CONTAINS COMMERCIAL CHEMICALS: There are 7 ingredients in Jell-O Black Cherry Artificial Flavor which are Not In Kitchen™ >> if we were making homemade fruit gelatin, we would not use Adipic Acid, Disodium Phosphate, Sodium Citrate or Fumaric Acid. We also would not use Artificial Flavor or 2 Artificial Colors - Red 40 and Blue 1.

WHY YOU WON'T SEE JELL-O AT WHOLE FOODS: Artificial Flavors and Artificial Colors are banned at Whole Foods Market who cites them as "Unacceptable in food." (Source: Amazon Whole Foods Web site 1/24).

Artificial Colors come with a warning in the European Union: "Warning: May have adverse effect on activity and attention in children.”

Once upon a time, Jell-O was all about Pure Fruit Flavor . . .

Discover food + beverages whose ingredients are Closest To Homemade in 275+ categories. Neither money nor products are ever accepted to appear on the Closest To Homemade list.

Follow us at: